Files
gbrain/BOOTSTRAP_FOR_AGENTS.md
Garry TanandClaude Fable 5 6411150071 v0.45.11.0 feat(bootstrap): OOBE hand-off (own the brain + cold-start) + DX polish waves (#4047)
* feat(bootstrap): TTY DX exploration harness + Krug onboarding fix wave

Add a real-PTY exploration harness and land 16 verified "Don't Make Me
Think" fixes on the paste-in install experience for Claude Code and Codex.

Harness:
- test/helpers/tty-harness.ts — spawns any CLI (gbrain/claude/codex) under a
  real pseudo-terminal (Bun terminal: spawn), timestamps every output burst,
  and turns silence windows into a measurable stall report. Hermetic; pure
  helpers unit-tested in test/tty-harness.test.ts.
- scripts/dx-explore.ts — drives the fresh-user funnel (help / init / real
  claude-install / real codex-install / manual drive mode), writing
  transcripts to .context/dx-runs/ (gitignored).

Fixes (all adversarially verified against the code first):
- Keyless bare `gbrain init` completes in keyless mode instead of exit 1;
  multi-key non-TTY auto-picks the canonical default; typo stays fail-loud.
- Provider picker probe-gates ollama (daemon-up != model-pulled) and offers
  an explicit "continue keyless" option that is the bare-Enter default.
- Fresh-brain init prints one schema-setup line instead of ~240 migration
  names (GBRAIN_MIGRATE_VERBOSE=1 restores detail).
- Init epilogue: memory-verbs funnel is last-on-screen; skills advisory
  compacted for init; Mod Status trimmed.
- PGLite live-serve lock error names the fix (close the agent session).
- Mode-picker banner interpolates the applied mode; expansion-key gate is
  Anthropic/OpenAI/Google, not OpenAI-only.
- Missing `claude` binary skips MCP but still installs hooks; honest copy.
- Foreign MCP-registration removal targets the conflicting scope and fails
  loud if it does not land.
- Upgrade marker compares the running binary to latest and self-spawns via
  execPath, so a current/newer binary no longer nags from a stale cache.
- interview --set/--skip after --confirm warns it voided the confirmation.
- init --help matches behavior; init --supabase fails loud on non-TTY.
- Provider capabilities attributed per provider across README / runbook /
  questions bank / bootstrap.md.
- First-run tour: restart-first, prompt 3 true on day one, withheld on FAIL;
  README gives Codex the same scripted magic moment.
- Empty-brain "0 takes" onboard nudge suppressed.
- Broken settings.local.json aborts the hooks write fail-closed instead of
  silently dropping the user's permissions.

Regenerated cli-flag-registry.generated.ts and llms-full.txt.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix(bootstrap): second DX polish wave — clean the success screen + honest copy (F17-F21)

Follow-up to the DX fix wave, closing the top-5 remaining gaps the scorecard
flagged (all human-facing polish, not survival):

F17 — machine markers no longer leak to humans:
- verify report drops the `[D3.6]` plan-tag from the first_run_tour detail.
- the raw `UPGRADE_AVAILABLE <cur> <latest>` marker line prints ONLY on a
  non-TTY stderr (parsers still get it); an interactive human sees just the
  "gbrain X -> Y available" sentence.
- per-migration "what changed" notices (v123/v124, incl. the #2704 ref) are
  suppressed on a FRESH-install replay via a module quiet flag; upgrades still
  narrate. (GBRAIN_MIGRATE_VERBOSE=1 restores them.)

F18 — one obvious next action on the init success screen: the memory-verbs
demo is the single "→ Do this next" hero, last on screen; import/migrate/doctor
collapse into one terse "More:" footer; the graph block only shows for a
non-empty brain.

F19 — README "moment it clicks" is now the genuine cross-session brain
round-trip (remember → restart → recall), explicitly distinguished from the
identity-file recall, on both the Codex and Claude Code paths.

F20 — the compact init skills advisory is human-voiced (no `[AGENT]`
stage-direction on the human-facing success screen; the mode-picker's
agent-directed block stays gated to the non-TTY channel).

F21 — time promise reconciled: headline is ~15 min (personal-agent path) /
~30 min (always-on OpenClaw/Hermes); the runbook's search-mode line no longer
claims "balanced" when keyless applies "conservative". README hooks copy says
"on by default, with an opt-out" to match the runbook.

Regenerated llms-full.txt.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

* fix(bootstrap): address two-model adversarial review of the DX wave

Fixes the regressions the 5-specialist + red-team + Claude/Codex adversarial
pass found in the F1–F21 changes, each with a test:

- Keyless upgrade hint pointed at `config set embedding_model`, which config.ts
  hard-refuses as a schema-sizing no-op — now names the working re-init recipe
  (`gbrain init --force --pglite --embedding-model <id>`), zero-key AND multi-key
  paths.
- Multi-key TTY picker offered "continue keyless" but the caller aborted on it —
  now honors keyless like the zero-key path.
- Detached update-refresh spawn used a `/gbrain$/` basename check that misfires
  for a renamed/official-named compiled binary (`gbrain-darwin-arm64`) and
  prepends the /$bunfs entrypoint — now detects dev-vs-compiled by the runtime
  basename (bun|node) so the refresh always runs.
- `bootstrap status` reported the wire phase "done" on a hooks-only receipt
  (host CLI missing at wire time) — now "partial" with a re-run hint, so a
  resuming agent doesn't trust a false complete.
- Post-repair MCP mismatch re-verifies and aborts instead of blessing a
  registration a racing writer may have re-claimed.
- probeOpenAICompat's abort timer now spans the body read (was cleared before
  it), so a stalled `/v1/models` body can't hang init past the 1s cap.
- Centralized the 4-copy stale-cache upgrade predicate into
  `pendingUpgradeVersion`; UPGRADE_AVAILABLE gains a GBRAIN_FORCE_UPGRADE_MARKER
  override for PTY-based agent harnesses.
- Mode picker's expansion-key gate adds GEMINI_API_KEY; picker prompt is
  article-aware ("an embedding" / "a chat"); dead `!brainEmpty` clause removed;
  migrate.ts try/finally widened + stamp failures named in quiet mode.
- DX harness: credential copies scrubbed even on SIGINT/interrupt (+chmod 600),
  child process TREE reaped on teardown, advisory made fail-open, KEY_MAP typed
  as a literal union.

New tests: migrate quiet-replay, self-upgrade pending predicate + negative
cache cases, bootstrap 127/scoped-remove/broken-settings dispatch, interview
invalidation flag, verify tour-withheld-on-FAIL, init keyless/supabase/multi-key,
init-nudge branches, ai-probes model parsing. Regenerated flag registry +
template-repo.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

* v0.45.8.0 fix(bootstrap): onboarding DX polish wave (F17-F21) + review fixes

DX fix wave on the paste-in install/first-run experience for Claude Code and
Codex, driven by a new real-PTY exploration harness. Keyless init completes
instead of erroring, the migration wall collapses to one line, the success
screen leads with one action, and the "magic moment" copy points at the genuine
cross-session round-trip. Full detail in CHANGELOG.

Version trio + openclaw manifest + runbook stamp bumped to 0.45.8.0; CHANGELOG
release entry; TODOS onboarding-DX follow-ups filed.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

* feat(bootstrap): OOBE hand-off — you own the brain, cold-start is skill #1

A working install now ends by making the two facts that matter actually land:

- `gbrain bootstrap verify` prints (and returns as `handoff` in --json) an
  ownership block — the actual private-repo URL with what owning it means
  (read it, `gbrain bootstrap attach` on machine two, delete it and the brain
  is gone), or the local-only variant pointing at `gbrain bootstrap repo` —
  followed by the ONE next action: run the cold-start skill (Gmail/calendar/
  contacts via ClawVisor, an OAuth vault so the agent never holds raw tokens;
  or offline archives), one consented phase at a time. Withheld on FAIL like
  the tour; shape stays unconditional for machine consumers.
- cold-start ships in the downstream bundle (61 skills): its plugin exclusion
  ("host onboarding flow") predated the v0.45 personal-agent bootstrap and is
  deliberately reversed — the paste-in audience is exactly who day-one
  onboarding is for. It now LEADS the recommended set (ahead of book-mirror:
  every flagship skill only becomes magical once the brain holds the user's
  real life).
- New drift guard: every recommended slug must be scaffoldable from the
  plugin bundle — recommended-but-unscaffoldable is a dead-end CTA and now
  fails the suite.
- Runbook Hand off rewritten around the two must-land facts + the on-the-spot
  cold-start offer; README's Codex and Claude Code paths carry the same two
  follow-ups.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

* v0.45.10.0 feat(bootstrap): the OOBE hand-off release

Version trio + runbook stamp + template tree to 0.45.10.0; CHANGELOG entry;
llms bundles regenerated.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

* test(ci): stop memory-verbs-conformance leaking a fake-keyed gateway into shard-mates

The deterministic-embedder helper configures the MODULE-GLOBAL gateway with a
fake OpenAI key; the file's afterAll never reset it. The bunfig preload's
per-test restore only fires when the gateway is UNCONFIGURED, so the fake-keyed
config persisted for every later file in the shard process — turn-context's
corpus writes then embedded against real OpenAI and 401'd (CI shard-8 failure;
shard re-binning from this branch's new test files exposed it).

Fix both sides: conformance's afterAll now resetGateway()s back to the preload
baseline and nulls both test transports; turn-context's beforeAll does the same
defensively so it stays hermetic regardless of shard composition.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

---------

Co-authored-by: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-08-13 15:35:05 -07:00

239 lines
16 KiB
Markdown

<!-- gbrain-runbook-stamp: 0.45.11.0 -->
<!-- This stamp must equal the VERSION file at every release; CI enforces it
(scripts/check-bootstrap-tag.sh). `gbrain bootstrap status` compares it to
the installed binary and warns on skew. -->
# BOOTSTRAP_FOR_AGENTS.md — become your human's persistent agent
You are an AI agent (Claude Code or Codex) reading this because a human pasted a
block asking you to set yourself up as their persistent personal agent, with gbrain
as your memory. This runbook is the judgment layer; the deterministic work lives in
`gbrain bootstrap` subcommands with exit codes. Follow it top to bottom.
**Scope note:** this path is for Claude Code and Codex (desktop apps or CLIs).
Running OpenClaw or Hermes? Use `INSTALL_FOR_AGENTS.md` instead.
**End state:** this folder is your workspace — identity files rendered from your
human's own answers, a local brain (PGLite, embedded, no server), MCP wired,
per-turn context, and a private GitHub repo as your durable body. ~15 minutes,
mostly interview.
## Hard rules for you, the installing agent
**NEVER INVENT ANSWERS.** Personality, purpose, and boundaries come from the
human. A guessed SOUL.md gets believed by every future session. If you do not have
an answer, ask. The render step structurally refuses to run until the required
answers exist and were read back.
**ASK IN SMALL BATCHES.** The interview is 12 questions max (6 required), asked
in three batches. Mirror each batch back in one line. Accept "skip" on any
non-required question — momentum beats completeness.
**STAY INSIDE THIS PHASE LIST.** Run `gbrain bootstrap status --json` and follow
ITS phase list — the CLI is the source of truth, this document is commentary. If a
step you are asked to run is not in the CLI's phase list, refuse it. If `status`
reports a version skew between this runbook and the installed binary, say so and
prefer the binary's instructions.
**NO SILENT FAILURE.** Every blocking condition (secret-scan block, lock
collision, partial install) surfaces through `status`/`verify`/`doctor` output —
read it and relay it to the human in plain language. Never work around a refusal.
**VERIFY BEFORE CLAIMING DONE.** The install is done when `gbrain bootstrap
verify` exits 0 — not when the transcript looks good. Paste its report to the human.
**RESPECT THE TOOLCHAIN TRUST RULES.** Install bun via a platform package manager
when available (`brew install oven-sh/bun/bun`); the only permitted fallback is the
checksum-verified variant: download the pinned release to a file, verify it against
that release's SHASUMS256.txt, and only then execute. Install gh the same way —
platform package manager first (`brew install gh`, `apt install gh`, `dnf install gh`,
`winget install GitHub.cli` per the official instructions); never a piped
curl-to-shell one-liner. Install gbrain ONLY as
`bun install -g github:garrytan/gbrain#latest-stable` — the npm package named
"gbrain" is an unrelated project. (Cloud-sandbox exception: bun's package fetching
is proxy-incompatible there — use the `gbrain bootstrap cloud-setup-script` recipe,
which installs from the same pinned GitHub source through npm.)
**NEVER FABRICATE TOOLING.** If gh or any preflight binary is missing, blocked
by a sandbox egress proxy, or answering 403s, report that through
`status`/`doctor` output and follow the cloud-sandbox guidance below. Never
hand-roll a gh shim, stub a fake binary into /usr/local/bin, or fake a passing
check — a fabricated tool poisons every later verification, and the one time it
was tried it masked a real silent-persistence failure. The CLI degrades honestly
on its own; your job is to relay, not to bridge.
## Codex preflight (ChatGPT desktop / Codex CLI only)
Codex sandboxes command execution. Before starting, tell the human: "I'll need
approval to run install commands (bun, gh, gbrain) and to write in this folder —
approve those prompts when they appear." If approvals are globally disabled, ask the
human to enable workspace-write + network for this session. Count the approval taps
you needed; report the count at the end (it feeds the install-time measurement).
## Phase walkthrough (commentary — the CLI's list wins)
1. **Preflight.** `git`, `bun`, `gh` present. Install what's missing per the trust
rules above: bun via a platform package manager or the checksum-verified download
— the checksum-verified install is the ONLY permitted non-package-manager
variant; gh via the platform package manager. (On a clean Mac, `git` may trigger
the Xcode tools dialog — that download does not count against the 15 minutes,
tell the human to let it run.)
`gh auth status` — if logged out, the human's ONE manual step:
`gh auth login -h github.com -p https -w` (you run it; they click Authorize).
Then `gbrain bootstrap status` — it is idempotent and resume-aware; after any
partial failure, re-run it and continue where it points.
2. **Engine.** `gbrain init --pglite` (2 seconds, no server). Search mode is
auto-selected silently (conservative when keyless, tokenmax with an
expansion key) and printed with an `[AGENT]` cost matrix — surface that
matrix to the human and confirm before running high-volume queries (see
INSTALL_FOR_AGENTS.md Step 3.5); they can change it any time with
`gbrain search modes`. The one thing to raise here is the OPTIONAL provider
key — with no key you run keyless: keyword search plus memory you author
yourself through the write tools; everything works, one key upgrades search to
semantic and enables automatic fact extraction. Never pressure for a key. If the
human provides one, pass it to the CLI prompt — it goes to the 0600 config file,
never into the interview answers, never into chat logs you keep.
3. **Interview.** `gbrain bootstrap interview --init`, then ask the questions from
the bank (the CLI prints them) in three batches, recording each answer verbatim
with `--set KEY "value"`. Push once on vague answers to the required questions.
Claude Code only: with the final batch, also ask the ONE operational consent —
MCP scope. It is not one of the 12 interview questions; consents ride alongside
the bank. The choice: project (recommended — any other repo you open cannot
read your brain) vs user (your agent everywhere, but any repo you open can
reach it — read and write — and two open sessions contend for the database).
Record it with
`gbrain bootstrap interview --set MCP_SCOPE <project|user>` BEFORE the
read-back, so the confirmation covers it. On Codex, skip this question
entirely — the wiring step states the Codex reality instead.
After the last batch: read ALL answers back in one compact block, ask "Is this
the thing you want in the room?", and only then run
`gbrain bootstrap interview --confirm <hash>` with the hash `--status` printed
for the read-back set. The gate fails if you confirm a set the human never saw.
4. **Render.** `gbrain bootstrap render` — identity files appear. Show the human
SOUL.md. Existing files are never overwritten (re-runs are safe; `--force`
backs up first).
5. **Skills.** `gbrain skillpack scaffold --all` — the CLI scaffolds the skill
set. Nothing to judge here; relay the output.
6. **Wire the harness + register the brain source.** `gbrain bootstrap hooks
--harness <detected>` creates `<workspace>/brain` and prints the exact
`gbrain sources add <source_id> --path <brain> --force` command for THIS
workspace — run it verbatim (don't guess a different id; a guessed id
only surfaces as an FK error at `verify` time, by which point a wrong
guess also blocks the correct id with an `overlapping_path` error). It
also:
- Claude Code: installs per-turn hooks ON by default — do NOT ask; loading the
brain every turn is the whole point of installing gbrain for your agent. Tell
the human it is on and how to turn it off (`GBRAIN_HOOKS=0`, or re-run with
`--no-hooks`, or `gbrain bootstrap uninstall`). MCP scope is NOT asked here —
`hooks` consumes the MCP_SCOPE answer recorded during the interview.
- Codex: registers MCP (`codex mcp add`) and relies on the AGENTS.md protocol —
say plainly that Codex gets pull-based context, not per-turn push.
Do NOT offer an MCP scope choice: `codex mcp add` has no scope flag, so
the registration is always user-global. State it as fact — any repo opened
on this machine can reach the brain (read and write) through its MCP
tools; the off-ramps are `codex mcp remove gbrain` (registration only) or
`gbrain bootstrap uninstall` (full teardown).
7. **Private repo.** `gbrain bootstrap repo` — creates a PRIVATE GitHub repo from
the workspace, verifies the privacy bit through the API, pushes. If the human
started from a repo they created themselves (create-repo-first: an EMPTY private
repo under their own account, cloned and opened here), this ADOPTS that repo
instead of creating one — verifies it is private and pushes the workspace. A
non-empty repo, or one owned by an org, is refused with a clear message (make an
empty personal repo, or run `gbrain bootstrap attach` for an existing agent
clone). Asks the background-persistence consent (a git post-commit auto-push
plus a 30-minute pull job for multi-machine freshness; declining still persists
via the per-turn and session-end pushes). If the human has no GitHub or declines:
local-only mode with an honest warning; `bootstrap repo` can run any time later.
Note: the per-turn/session push stays deferred until this phase records the
verified repo, so nothing is ever pushed to an unverified-privacy origin.
8. **Verify.** `gbrain bootstrap verify` — the whole contract: brain round-trip
through the real write path, graph floor, token sweep, secret scan, repo
privacy, hooks smoke, capability report (keyless or keyed). Exit 0 or it is not
done. Paste the report. Then relay the first-run tour it prints (three prompts
the human should try, starting with restarting the session) AND the hand-off
block below it — the ownership line and the cold-start offer are the two
things the human must actually understand, not fine print.
## Machine two
If this workspace was cloned from an existing agent repo (agent.json says
initialized), run `gbrain bootstrap attach` instead of the interview/render/repo
phases — it wires this machine (source, hooks, MCP) and verifies. If agent.json
says it is an uninitialized template, proceed with the normal flow from phase 1.
## Cloud sandboxes (claude.ai/code and similar proxied environments)
**How you know:** `gbrain bootstrap status --json` reports
`execution_environment: "cloud-sandbox"` (the CLI detects the documented
signals — the CLAUDE_CODE_REMOTE env var, the proxy-injected token
placeholder). Trust the CLI's detection over your own guesses.
**Expected degradations — these are facts to relay, not bugs to bridge:**
- **No crontab, no surviving background processes.** The VM is reclaimed after
inactivity. The scheduled pull is skipped honestly; the per-turn (Stop hook)
and session-end pushes carry persistence. Decline nothing, fabricate nothing.
- **GitHub GraphQL is always blocked** by the egress proxy, and **REST reaches
only repos attached to the session** — a repo created mid-session is NOT
attached, so `gbrain bootstrap repo` refuses fast in cloud with the flow
that works. Privacy verification falls back to pure git protocol on its own.
- **`git push` works only against the session's working branch.** A user PAT
does not bypass any of this.
- **Only repo-committed files carry into the next session.** `~/.gbrain`,
`~/.claude`, and the gitignored `.claude/settings.local.json` evaporate.
Hooks therefore live in the COMMITTED `.claude/settings.json` (the CLI
writes PATH-resolved, fail-open commands there in cloud); hook config is
snapshotted at session start, so hooks written mid-session activate on the
NEXT session — say so instead of debugging it.
**The correct cloud flow:**
1. The human creates the private repo from a normal machine (or github.com)
and opens the cloud session ON that repo.
2. The environment's setup script installs the gbrain binary — print it with
`gbrain bootstrap cloud-setup-script` and have the human paste it into the
environment config (npm-based; bun's fetching is proxy-incompatible there).
3. Inside the session: `gbrain bootstrap attach`, then
`gbrain bootstrap hooks --harness claude-code` (writes the committed
carrier), commit + push, and tell the human the hooks go live next session.
## Failure modes, and what they actually mean
| Symptom | Real cause | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| `interview --status` exits nonzero forever | A required answer is genuinely missing | Ask the human. Do not default it. |
| Render refuses with unresolved tokens | Interview incomplete or a template edit broke a token | Finish the interview; `status` names the tokens. |
| `verify` fails the magic-moment check | The fact never landed (keyless: the Facts fence was not written) | Re-run the write step it names; check `gbrain doctor`. |
| Secret-scan block on push | A credential-shaped string in a tracked file | Fix or allowlist deliberately (`.gbrain-scan-allow`); never force. |
| "bootstrap already running (pid N)" | A concurrent bootstrap holds the lock | Wait or investigate that pid; the lock self-clears when stale. |
| Brain tools fail with a lock error | Another live session's serve owns the database | Close the other session; sequential use is the v1 contract. |
| Hook reports "brain context unavailable" | serve not running or degraded | `gbrain doctor` names it; hooks fail open by design. |
| gh answers 403 "not enabled for this session" | Cloud proxy scoping — the repo is not attached to the session | Expected in cloud; the visibility ladder falls back to git protocol. NEVER shim gh. |
| "crontab: command not found" / cron skipped | Containers and cloud sandboxes ship without a scheduler | Expected; event-driven pushes cover it — the skip message says exactly this. |
| A turn shows "workspace push is FAILING" | The background push is refusing (visibility, secret-scan, or network reasons) | Run `gbrain doctor`; the banner repeats every 30 min until fixed. |
## Hand off
Two things the human must UNDERSTAND before you finish — say them plainly, in
this order, and confirm they landed:
1. **They own the brain.** Every memory you keep is a markdown file in THEIR
private GitHub repo — name the URL. Owning it means: they can read it any
time, take it to a second machine (`gbrain bootstrap attach`), or delete the
repo and the brain is gone. If they went local-only, say that instead, with
`gbrain bootstrap repo` as the any-time upgrade.
2. **The first skill to run is cold-start.** An empty brain is a database; a
filled one is a memory — and every flagship skill (book-mirror, briefings,
meeting prep) only becomes magical once the brain holds their real life.
OFFER to run the cold-start skill now: it imports Gmail, calendar, and
contacts through ClawVisor (clawvisor.com — an OAuth vault; you never hold
raw tokens), or offline archives (Google Takeout, a notes folder) if they
prefer no third-party gateway. Every phase is consent-gated and
independently valuable — they can stop after any one. If they say "later",
that is a complete install; they can say "fill my brain" any time.
Then the routine facts: the capability mode (keyless vs keyed), and the three
commands they will actually reuse (`gbrain doctor`, `gbrain bootstrap verify`,
`gbrain sources push`). Then delete nothing — this runbook was fetched, not
installed.